Armenian Genocide remembrance

The Armenian Genocide was a campaign of deportation, forced marches, and mass murder during World War I, carried out by the Ottoman Empire against ethnic Armenians. It is believed that approximately 2 million Armenians were killed by the Ottomans.

The vast number of memorials and momuments dedicated to the Armenian Genocide serve as a painful reminder of the atrocities committed by the Ottoman Empire.

Understand

Background

The Armenian Genocide has a long and complicated background, which began in the early age of nationalism in the Ottoman Empire. The empire, for most of its history, was a multi-cultural, multi-religious one, which fostered a culture of pluralism that, while not egalitarian in any way, was unique for European empires in the early modern period.

However, in the 18th and 19th centuries, the age of nationalism brought ideas of self-governance, equality among people, but also scientific racism to the reaches of the Ottoman Empire. As the call for reforms and equal rights for non-Muslims strengthened during the mid 19th century, the Ottoman Empire was forced to sign the Edict of Gülhane and the Edict of Imperial Reform, aiming to create a unified Ottoman identity, in which Muslims and non-Muslims were equal. These reforms, while ambitious, not only failed to create this unified identity, but also ushered in a new era of European influence, which replaced the morally lenient, pluralist Ottoman culture with European culture, and emphasized the role of ethnic and national identity in the empire.

In retaliation, the Ottoman government, under the rule of the infamously authoritarian Abdulhamid II, began to pursue a policy of pan-Islamism. This rejection of both European demands for equality and traditional Ottoman pluralism ultimately lead to the Hamidian massacres, when disorganized Ottoman forces killed at least 100.000 Armenians. After this, many European nations demanded better conditions for Armenians in the empire, an issue that was framed at the time as the Armenian Question.

The reign of Abdulhamid II ended with the Young Turk revolution, which, at least in its very beginning, emphasized equality between ethnicities and religions. However, the party that came into power, the Committee of Union and Progress (CUP), once a diverse coalition of everyone from left-wing nationalists, liberals, and what might best be called proto-fascists, began to center around the Three Pashas: Enver Pasha, Talat Pasha, and Djemal Pasha.

The Three Pashas were famously ultranationalistic and tried to 'Turkify' the empire. At first, these changes were limited to place names (a practice that still continues to this day) but they were later expanded to practices of assimilation. These practices were generally unpopular, especially with non-Turks, and as the Ottomans entered WWI, the Three Pashas, paranoid about possible resistance to their actions, began to execute their 'solution' to the Armenian Question.

Genocide

The genocide began in April 1915, when the Ottoman government in Istanbul rounded up hundreds of Armenian intellectuals and deported them to Ankara. Soon afterward, an order was issued to relocate ethnic Armenians away from Turkish-inhabited areas through death marches. Many regional governors objected to or hesitated to accept this order at first, but were either relocated or forced to accept with military pressure.

The general public had a range of opinions. Some, especially those in certain religious sects such as the Mevlevi Order, hid Armenians from authorities, often facing death themselves, as they thought of the genocide as a gross violation of their religious and moral values, while some actively endorsed and contributed to the genocide. The majority, however, either chose or were forced to sit idly as the massacres continued.

The relocations and massacres were further accelerated after the siege of Van, during which Armenian defenders attempted to resist the Ottoman armies. This gave the Ottoman government a key excuse for the genocide, which denialists and justifiers use even to this day: that Armenians were Russian collaborators, and the Pashas simply had no other choice other than forcing Armenians out of the Russian borders. This excuse does not stand to scrutiny, however, considering that those who did manage to survive the marches were sent to extermination camps located along the present-day borders of Iraq and Syria, among many other reasons. The systematic nature of the killings died down after 1918, but massacres continued until the Republic of Turkey was established in 1923. Starting in 1919, the perpetrators who had not already fled Turkey were court-martialed, but the Pashas had already fled the country.

Legacy

April 24 is Armenian Genocide Remembrance Day, observed in Armenia and a few other countries.

As of 2022, more than 33 countries — such as United States, Canada, Brazil, Switzerland, Germany, Vatican City, and Russia — have formally recognised the Armenian Genocide. Denial of the Armenian Genocide is a punishable offence in many member states of the European Union and Switzerland, and academics and scholars consider it unethical to deny the event.

Only three countries actively deny the Armenian Genocide: Turkey, Azerbaijan, and Pakistan.

The Armenian Genocide is a highly controversial subject of discussion in Turkey. The Turkish government continues to deny that the Armenian Genocide ever took place, and resents the Armenian government for regularly bringing it up at international forums. Turkey has long utilised its alliances to campaign against the recognition of the event. A lot of Turks share the Turkish government's views on the Armenian Genocide. The few Turks who are brave enough to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide are either charged with "insulting Turkishness", subjected to threats and intimidation or labelled as "traitors". The Turkish government has been regularly criticised for its denialist stance, and very few institutions and individuals take the Turkish government's views seriously.

As a result of the genocide, the historical region of Western Armenia was largely ethnically cleansed of its Armenian population, and today is a part of Turkey, while the modern country of Armenia comprises only the eastern half of the historical Armenian lands. The result of this is that Mount Ararat, the holiest site in the world to ethnic Armenians, lies in Turkish territory today.

Sites

Armenia

• Tsitsernkaberd Armenian Genocide Memorial, 8/8 Tsitsernakaberd highway 0028, Yerevan, Armenia, 40.185821°, 44.488114°, +374 10 391412, info@genocide-museum.am. 10am-17pm; closed on Mondays. Armenia's official memorial dedicated to the victims of the Armenian genocide, and it is perhaps the most visited genocide memorial in the world. Admission is free of charge and all visitors are encouraged to donate. Eating, drinking, and smoking are strictly prohibited. 2022-10-03

Brazil

• Armenian Genocide monument, Armenia Square (São Paulo/Downtown, metro "Armenia"), -23.5259442°, -46.6310358°. Inaugurated in 1966. 2018-06-26

United States

• Armenian Heritage Park, Rose Kennedy Greenway, Atlantic Ave &, Mercantile St, Boston, Massachusetts, 42.360916°, -71.053206°, hello@ArmenianHeritagePark.org. Memorial park dedicated to victims of the Armenian Genocide. 2022-10-03

• Montebello Genocide Memorial (Armenian Genocide Martyrs Memorial Monument), 901 Via San Clemente, Montebello, California, 34.0284°, -118.131°, info@armenianmonument.org. Monument dedicated to victims of the Armenian Genocide. Has been visited by people such as Ronald Reagan, Arnold Schwarzenegger, and so on. 2022-10-03

Cope

Visiting the sites of the Armenian Genocide can be emotional, upsetting, and sometimes surreal. You'll see and learn things that are difficult to grapple with, and it's hard to anticipate exactly how you'll react. You may find yourself hurrying to get away from the site as quickly as you can, morose and weary as you physically feel the weight of what you're seeing, or unexpectedly detached and distant—or some combination of these.

Given the evil nature of the crimes committed in the Armenian Genocide, you would be forgiven for thinking the places where the crimes were perpetrated would look in some way evil too, or be in isolated locations tucked out of sight. This is not always the case, and the surroundings may often be positively mundane, and be in close proximity to roads, homes and workplaces filled with people going about their daily lives. The sun may be shining. It is this contrast between expectation and reality, or between horror and banality, that can cause you to feel strangely disoriented.

Be prepared for complicated and heavy emotions, and do not expect to just move on cheerfully to your next activity once you leave. Conversely, you may need to do just that. Your experience at the site may weigh on you for the rest of the day and beyond.

Respect

The Armenian Genocide, the atrocities committed by the Ottoman Empire, and the Turkish government's denialist stance have caused many people to have negative perceptions of Turkey and Turkish people. Do not let the Armenian Genocide colour your perception of an entire country and its people; there are good and bad things about Turkey much in the same way there are good and bad people in Turkey.

When visiting memorials and monuments, consider donating; this will leave a good impression on people.

When discussing the Armenian Genocide with Armenians and people of Armenian descent, approach the subject with civility and respect and offer sympathy as and when required; they will appreciate the gesture.

Never openly deny the existence of the Armenian Genocide; you will deeply offend many people and it is, to a large extent, akin to hate speech. Further, openly denying the Armenian Genocide is a crime in Greece, Italy, Slovakia, Switzerland, and Cyprus.